Tiada rusuhan pada malam pertama curfew bersasar di Perancis, skop sambungan dan batas hak masih perlu diperjelas

Selon France 24, manifestasi hujung minggu di Perancis telah berkembang menjadi rusuhan sebelum’autoriti_country Pratt实施 langkah_dump membImplemented curfew bersasar. Curfew itu walkers实行_els didn’t_result dalam rusuhan pada malam pertama Interrupted its implementation. Perdana Menteri Sebastien Lecornuilh said the Government would continue the measure on Tuesday in areas considered necessary.

However, the report did not specify exactly which cities were affected, the curfew hours, who it applied to, the legal basis for the authorities’ powers, the penalties for violations, or any exemptions. It therefore remains difficult for the public to assess the curfew’s actual scope and duration, or whether the restrictions are proportionate to the security risks they are intended to address.

The absence of riots on the first night shows only that no riots occurred during that particular period. It does not demonstrate a causal relationship between the curfew and a reduction in conflict, nor does it indicate that the causes of the weekend demonstrations or the damage caused by the riots have been resolved. As a measure of public authority that directly restricts nighttime movement and public activity, a curfew cannot be regarded as effective merely because no riots occurred on its first night. The report also did not provide the views of affected residents, traders or event organisers, making it impossible to verify how the benefits and costs of the restrictions are distributed.

Following Lecornu’s announcement that the curfew would continue on Tuesday, the Government should clarify the affected locations, applicable periods and groups, as well as spell out the legal authorisation and penalty rules. It should also state the conditions for lifting the restrictions once the risk has subsided. Otherwise, continuing the measure solely on the basis of a quiet first night, without clear details, leaves its necessity unproven.